Flu Vaccines Often Protect Less Than Cited
Adults who get the annual flu shot should know its protection against infection has often fallen below the commonly cited range.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Diseases — General

Live Poll
Do you think the flu shot protects you as well as health officials claim?
A University of Maryland analysis published in JAMA Network Open finds that flu vaccine effectiveness has often fallen below the commonly cited 40% to 60% range. The study reviewed end-of-season estimates from 18 flu seasons, and this matters for adults who rely on annual vaccination as a key defense as flu spreads early this season.
Why it matters
Flu vaccines are reformulated each year to match expected strains, so their protection depends heavily on how well the chosen vaccine matches the viruses that actually circulate. Understanding how often that match falls short helps explain why effectiveness varies and why researchers are pushing for vaccines with broader protection.
This analysis pooled end-of-season effectiveness estimates from flu seasons spanning 2004-2005 through 2023-2024 and also checked whether each season's vaccine matched the circulating strains. Its median effectiveness of 39.5% in preventing infection falls below the commonly cited range, and the vaccine was not well matched in 11 of the 18 seasons studied.
The players
University of Maryland
A public research university whose researchers conducted the analysis of flu vaccine effectiveness across multiple seasons.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
The U.S. federal agency that tracks flu burden, estimates deaths and hospitalizations, and reports the lives saved by vaccination each season.
The details
Each year's flu vaccine is designed around predictions of which influenza strains will circulate, so a closer match between vaccine and virus generally produces stronger protection. When the predicted strains differ from the ones that spread, the vaccine can offer less protection even though it is still working as intended. The researchers found that effectiveness estimates were often predicated on this kind of match, which is why mismatched seasons pull the overall picture down.
Timeline
2004-2005: First flu season included in the vaccine effectiveness analysis
2023-2024: Last flu season included; CDC estimates vaccination saved 7,900 lives
Nov. 10, 2026: Study published in JAMA Network Open
Nov. 16, 2026: University of Maryland news release issued
Health Landscape
Influenza is among the leading causes of death from infectious disease in the United States, with the CDC estimating between 6,300 and 52,000 deaths in a typical year. The new analysis adds to the case for influenza vaccines that protect more broadly across shifting strains, an area of ongoing research.
Because vaccine protection varies from season to season, getting vaccinated each year remains the main step most adults can take against flu, and it is worth raising with your doctor when you schedule your shot. Adults at higher risk of severe flu should discuss the timing and type of vaccine that fits their situation with a clinician.
The takeaway
Flu vaccines usually reduce risk but often work less well than the commonly cited range suggests, which is why yearly vaccination and early conversations with your doctor still matter. Ask your clinician whether this season's vaccine is a good fit for your health history.
Further reading
For broader context on how infections spread and are controlled, explore our Diseases — General coverage.
Live Poll
Do you think the flu shot protects you as well as health officials claim?





